Novelo Logo
Loading

Review Swaps?

8Replies
102Views
Created
Last Reply
Replied
# 1

Hello, I am looking to do a few review swaps. Four chapters for four chapters. Or however we agree to do it.

Edit
Replied
# 2

Sure!

Report
Replied
Edited
# 3

posted

Hello, I am looking to do a few review swaps. Four chapters for four chapters. Or however we agree to do it.

Hi Pens&Keys


I'd be happy to swap reviews - story for story! Let me know if you're interested.

Report
Replied
# 4

Matthew

posted

Sure!

My apologizes I am only just now seeing this.

If you are still available so am I

Edit
Delete
Replied
# 5

BillBow

posted
Edited

Hi Pens&Keys


I'd be happy to swap reviews - story for story! Let me know if you're interested.

Your story is completed?

Edit
Delete
Replied
Edited
# 6

posted

Your story is completed?

Yes. My story is completed. It's in the January Challenge: Gold Bug Resolution. Please check it out. Review stars and feedback comments gratefully received.


Which story of yours would you like feedback on?


I can give you overall content feedback - commenting on the big picture and the general shape of the story. I usually do this publicly when I give your story review stars.


I can also give you a line edit feedback - noting typos, grammar and punctuation issues, and also highlighting. good/effective phrases you've used. I prefer to do this nitty-gritty feedback more privately in a discussion thread.


Let me know what kind of feedback you'd like on the story you want me to look at.

Report
Replied
# 7

BillBow

posted
Edited

Yes. My story is completed. It's in the January Challenge: Gold Bug Resolution. Please check it out. Review stars and feedback comments gratefully received.


Which story of yours would you like feedback on?


I can give you overall content feedback - commenting on the big picture and the general shape of the story. I usually do this publicly when I give your story review stars.


I can also give you a line edit feedback - noting typos, grammar and punctuation issues, and also highlighting. good/effective phrases you've used. I prefer to do this nitty-gritty feedback more privately in a discussion thread.


Let me know what kind of feedback you'd like on the story you want me to look at.

I believe 'I can give you overall content feedback - commenting on the big picture and the general shape of the story.' Is very important for me right now. My story is "Alucard St.Vincent."


I can do the same for your story as well.

Edit
Delete
Replied
# 8

posted

I believe 'I can give you overall content feedback - commenting on the big picture and the general shape of the story.' Is very important for me right now. My story is "Alucard St.Vincent."


I can do the same for your story as well.

Hi there,


I have given you a general review of Chapter 1 of your story 'Alucard St. Vincent'. I hope you find my comments thought-provoking but useful. I did notice some typos and punctuation mistakes along the way, which I would personally recommend weeding out. (It's the first impression a reader gets of you, after all!) However, as you requested, I have not commented on those but offered you instead just a content edit.


Please do take a look at 'Gold Bug Resolution' and give me a review/some comments on it. After you've done that, if you like, I can have a look at Chapter 2 of Alucard St. Vincent (or Lucarda San Genaro)! I'm intrigued to see how your story develops.

Report
Showing 1 - 8 of 8 results